Editing Vote for the Girls (United States) moderator policies
Your changes will be displayed to readers once an authorized user accepts them. (help) |
Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.
The edit can be undone.
Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then save the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
Latest revision | Your text | ||
Line 217: | Line 217: | ||
==Flexible Picks== | ==Flexible Picks== | ||
− | Since the [[Vote for the Girls (U.S. cycle 10)|spring cycle]] of the sixth season, the web site has used a "flexible pick" system for the main moderator panel of the regular competitions when there is a male Vote for the Girls pick<ref name=VFTGUSA_FlexPick>http:// | + | Since the [[Vote for the Girls (U.S. cycle 10)|spring cycle]] of the sixth season, the web site has used a "flexible pick" system for the main moderator panel of the regular competitions when there is a male Vote for the Girls pick<ref name=VFTGUSA_FlexPick>http://www.voteforthegirls.us/about/flexible-picks</ref>. This is because as early as the Top 6 of American Idol or the Quarter-Finals of The Voice, there are a number of the web site's supported contestants that have been eliminated or at risk of elimination (and a Vote for the Girls loss). Flex-picks ensures that all moderators have finale significance, regardless of whether or not one main moderator is competing for a finale spot. Two examples of this type of flexing involved the [[Thia Tola]] on the fourteenth season of American Idol and on the eighth season of The Voice. In the first instance, the web site's male picks of Daniel Seavey and Nick Fradiani (chosen by [[Ava Zinn]] and [[Kymberly Alvaraz]] under the Alex & Sierra rule) |
− | Zinn and Alvaraz's lone supported contestant, [[wikipedia:Nick Fradiani|Nick Fradiani]] was saved by the American public vote while Kendra Ray's supported contestant [[wikipedia:Maddie Walker|Maddie Walker]] and Zinn and Alvaraz's supported contestant [[wikipedia:Adanna Duru|Adanna Duru]] were both eliminated with [[wikipedia:Sarina-Joi Crowe|Sarina-Joi Crowe]], resulting in not only Ray, [[Julia Passalt]], and [[Rhonda Rhodes]] with any remaining picks on their teams, but the elimination resulted in | + | Zinn and Alvaraz's lone supported contestant, [[wikipedia:Nick Fradiani|Nick Fradiani]] was saved by the American public vote while Kendra Ray's supported contestant [[wikipedia:Maddie Walker|Maddie Walker]] and Zinn and Alvaraz's supported contestant [[wikipedia:Adanna Duru|Adanna Duru]] were both eliminated with [[wikipedia:Sarina-Joi Crowe|Sarina-Joi Crowe]], resulting in not only Ray, [[Julia Passalt]], and [[Rhonda Rhodes]] with any remaining picks on their teams, but the elimination resulted in an all-pink team moderator Top 9 for the first time in the web site's history [[Kymberly Alvaraz|six Pink Team]] [[Holly Everman|female]] [[Kellie Rock|moderators]] [[Lanise White|earned]] [[Thia Tola|immunity]] [[Tracia Ward|by default]], (Tracia Ward eventually became the joint winning moderator after her pick [[wikipedia:Jax (singer)|Jax Cole]] finished 3rd and Fradiani's victory over the web site's Vote for the Worst pick (Clark Beckham) resulted in Zinn's 11th moderator victory and the first for Ward and Alvaraz.) The next week, Zinn and Alvaraz's pick of [[wikipedia:Meghan Linsey|Meghan Linsey]] and Tola's pick of eventual ''Voice'' season 8 winner [[wikipedia:Sawyer Fredericks|Sawyer Fredericks]], who had been projected to win based on iTunes votes; hence, the picks of Fredericks and Linsey were declared joint victories. |
− | This system also allows primary Vote for the Girls picks that enjoy unexpected success to acquire a frontrunner spot that was not on their original picks. Home picks based on the supported female contestant and the moderator's hometown are fixed in place and cannot be changed, as are male contestants not supported by the web site, as it was in the spring of 2014 (the site supported [[wikipedia:Christina Grimmie|Christina Grimmie]] instead of Indianapolis' Josh Kaufman as the web site declared him as a Vote for the Worst pick instead). It also increases the potential for a male and female victory in addition to to an all-female finale or even an all-female Final 2, as occurred in 2011 on the eighth season of ''So You Think You Can Dance'', 2013 on the twelfth season of ''Idol'' and the fourth and fifth seasons of ''The Voice'' (Zinn was the only remaining moderator during the fifth season of ''The Voice'' after the eliminations of Olivia Henken, Shelbie Z, Grey, and Tamara Chaunice that were chosen by [[Holly Everman|her]] [[Hillary Matthewson|opposing]] [[Michelle Steele|moderators]], resulting in Zinn's picks of eventual ''Voice'' season 5 winner [[wikipedia:Tessanne Chin|Tessane Chin]] and runner-up [[wikipedia:Jacquie Lee|Jacquie Lee]] guaranteed Zinn her ninth moderator victory after the third place finish of [[wikipedia:Will Champlin|Will Champlin]] | + | This system also allows primary Vote for the Girls picks that enjoy unexpected success to acquire a frontrunner spot that was not on their original picks. Home picks based on the supported female contestant and the moderator's hometown are fixed in place and cannot be changed, as are male contestants not supported by the web site, as it was in the spring of 2014 (the site supported [[wikipedia:Christina Grimmie|Christina Grimmie]] instead of Indianapolis' Josh Kaufman as the web site declared him as a Vote for the Worst pick instead). It also increases the potential for a male and female victory in addition to to an all-female finale or even an all-female Final 2, as occurred in 2011 on the eighth season of ''So You Think You Can Dance'', 2013 on the twelfth season of ''Idol'' and the fourth and fifth seasons of ''The Voice'' (Zinn was the only remaining moderator during the fifth season of ''The Voice'' after the eliminations of Olivia Henken, Shelbie Z, Grey, and Tamara Chaunice that were chosen by [[Holly Everman|her]] [[Hillary Matthewson|opposing]] [[Michelle Steele|moderators]], resulting in Zinn's picks of eventual ''Voice'' season 5 winner [[wikipedia:Tessanne Chin|Tessane Chin]] and runner-up [[wikipedia:Jacquie Lee|Jacquie Lee]] guaranteed Zinn her ninth moderator victory after the third place finish of [[wikipedia:Will Champlin|Will Champlin]]). |
− | Under the system, most of the web site's supported contestants in the affected affected competitions are on ''American Idol'' and/or ''The Voice'' will tentatively have the three, four or five female frontrunners depending on the competition. Also, the shared moderator markets of | + | Under the system, most of the web site's supported contestants in the affected affected competitions are on ''American Idol'' and/or ''The Voice'' will tentatively have the three, four or five female frontrunners depending on the competition. Also, the shared moderator markets of Indianapolis/Fort Wayne (Zinn, Jameson, Ward and Everman), Chicago (Jameson and Ward), Denver (Alvaraz and Dwyars), Milwaukee (White and Dwayar) and San Francisco (Tola and Johnson) cannot protect supported male contestants outside the moderator's home market. |
− | During the last week of the season, Zinn could re-assign the web site's supported contestants as late as the semi-finals so that as many of the main moderator panelists as possible will be able to promote votes for a supported contestant that has major finale implications, and so that spots are on the line at the same time. The competition's finale is decided exclusively by either the moderator panel to use their Moderators' Save on a female contestant (either on the last remaining female contestant or based on her earlier audition); the moderator panel cannot protect or choose during the final week. This example happened in the only season of ''Rising Star'' concerning Audrey Kate Geiger (chosen by Kellie Rock) and Dana Williams (chosen by Zinn). Both Rock and Zinn had supported contestants that were previously saved by the west coast with major finale implications that could have all but eliminated the two remaining male contestants (Jessie Kinch and Austin French) contention with a victory. Instead, Geiger and Williams respectively finished third and fourth on ''Rising Star'' resulting in a loss, of which was the third of a six-competition losing streak (not counting the Moderators' Saves of Valerie Rockey and DaNica Shirey). These losses eventually lead to Zinn implementing the | + | During the last week of the season, Zinn could re-assign the web site's supported contestants as late as the semi-finals so that as many of the main moderator panelists as possible will be able to promote votes for a supported contestant that has major finale implications, and so that spots are on the line at the same time. The competition's finale is decided exclusively by either the moderator panel to use their Moderators' Save on a female contestant (either on the last remaining female contestant or based on her earlier audition); the moderator panel cannot protect or choose during the final week. This example happened in the only season of ''Rising Star'' concerning Audrey Kate Geiger (chosen by Kellie Rock) and Dana Williams (chosen by Zinn). Both Rock and Zinn had supported contestants that were previously saved by the west coast with major finale implications that could have all but eliminated the two remaining male contestants (Jessie Kinch and Austin French) contention with a victory. Instead, Geiger and Williams respectively finished third and fourth on ''Rising Star'' resulting in a loss, of which was the third of a six-competition losing streak (not counting the Moderators' Saves of Valerie Rockey and DaNica Shirey). These losses eventually lead to Zinn implementing the dual victory format beginning in the web site's spring cycle. |
− | Individual moderators on the | + | Individual moderators on the main panel may make no more than four supported male contestants on any regular competition during the season. Only the defending winning moderator(s) from the previous season can as many as five supported male contestants per season.<ref name=VFTGUSA_FlexPick/> The remaining moderators may make a maximum of four supported male contestants. |
− | Beginning in the web site's seventh season, Zinn | + | Beginning in the web site's seventh season, Zinn will also be able to "cross-flex" supported contestants between the main moderator and male moderator crew, allowing the site's Pink and Purple Team moderators flexibility in selecting as many as two male contestants on her team. During the opening round, as well as the standard Vote for the Girls picks (which are typically female contestants), in which each woman on the pink team and transwoman on the purple team (including Zinn and Everman) could use once and only once during the entire season. Making that male Vote for the Girls pick based on his vocals and appearance would automatically disqualify the opposing pink or purple team from making that pick and must be declared her Vote for the Worst pick, regardless of the other moderators' opinions. |
− | + | This is being implemented to prevent the web site's Vote for the Worst picks from airing during the competition, while at the same time attracting the coveted Female 18-49 demographic compared to the Male demographic, finale-potential male-female finale matchup that more fans would enjoy watching. | |
==References== | ==References== |